Brachial Plexus Injury After Shoulder Arthroscopy in Korea: A 280 Million Won Appellate Result
2026 Nov
Case Overview
A woman in her fifties visited an orthopedic department because her right shoulder dislocated repeatedly and caused pain. MRI imaging showed a tear at the front of the shoulder joint, together with stretching of the capsule that surrounds the joint, and she underwent arthroscopic surgery the following day.
Before the general anesthetic, an anesthesiologist administered a brachial plexus block, a regional technique in which local anesthetic is injected around the bundle of nerves that runs from the neck, past the armpit, and into the arm.
Her shoulder pain continued after the operation and was still being reported at discharge. The hospital responded with pain medication and physical therapy. During roughly three months of outpatient follow-up she also described numbness in her fingers and weakness in the arm, but care remained limited to observation and manual therapy. A nerve study at another university hospital eventually confirmed damage to the brachial plexus involving the radial and axillary nerves. She lost the ability to extend her wrist and fingers and later underwent tendon transfer surgery, yet weakness, muscle wasting, joint stiffness and loss of sensation in her right hand remained permanent. A court-ordered physical assessment placed her loss of earning capacity at 65.5 percent.
Taeshin Law Firm filed a damages claim against the orthopedic surgeon who operated, the anesthesiologist, and the hospital operator.
Background
The brachial plexus is the network of nerves that supplies movement and sensation to the shoulder, arm and hand. It lies close to the field used in shoulder surgery, which is why both the operation and the anesthesia given for it can place it at risk. During arthroscopic shoulder surgery the arm is held in a position that opens the joint, and traction may be applied to create working space. Positioning and traction alike can stretch the plexus. A brachial plexus block, performed to control pain during and after the operation, adds a separate point of exposure, because the needle and the anesthetic are delivered beside those same nerves.
Nerve injury does not always announce itself at once. A patient coming out of surgery may attribute numbness or weakness to the operation itself, to swelling, or to the lingering effect of the block, and clinicians may make the same assumption. The consequences of a missed injury can be substantial. If nerve damage is not identified and managed, weakness can progress, muscles can waste, joints can stiffen, and sensation may never return.
Medical Issue
The central medical question was whether the client's brachial plexus was injured during the operation and the anesthesia, and whether the care that followed allowed the injury to become permanent.
Shoulder arthroscopy is generally regarded as less invasive than open surgery, but it is not risk-free. Traction applied to the arm in order to distract the joint places tension on the brachial plexus. Clinical guidance generally calls for traction to be kept modest, on the order of a small fraction of the patient's body weight, precisely to limit that tension. The operative record in this case documented additional traction of 10 kilograms.
The anesthesia introduced a second source of risk. A brachial plexus block places anesthetic near the nerves. Ultrasound guidance is commonly used to visualize the nerve bundle and the needle, and its absence can increase the chance of inadvertent contact with a nerve or of an injection into tissue around it.
The postoperative course raised a third question. The client reported pain that did not follow the expected pattern and, at follow-up visits, numbness and weakness. A nerve conduction study or comparable objective testing could have distinguished a temporary effect of the block from structural nerve damage. It was not arranged for about three months, and the diagnosis was ultimately made at another hospital.
Key Legal Issues
The first issue concerned the surgical and anesthetic technique. The claim alleged that the traction applied during the operation exceeded what was appropriate and that the block was performed without ultrasound guidance, increasing the risk of nerve injury. The operative record stated 10 kilograms of additional traction. The medical record appraisal responded that traction should be kept to roughly one tenth of the patient's body weight or less in order to protect the plexus.
The second issue concerned postoperative care. Once the client described numbness and weakness, the claim argued, the hospital was obliged to investigate rather than continue observation and manual therapy. The outpatient notes recorded a numb thumb, a weak arm and wrist drop, findings that point to nerve dysfunction, yet no additional testing was ordered for about three months.
The third issue concerned informed consent. The surgical consent form did not describe the brachial plexus block, and the explanation of the block and its risks was given to the person accompanying the client rather than to the client herself. The claim argued that this did not satisfy the duty to explain a procedure and its risks to the patient.
The defense offered a different account. It maintained that the surgery and anesthesia were performed properly, that the recorded 10 kilograms was in fact 10 pounds, about 4.5 kilograms, and had been entered incorrectly by a nurse, that the client had never reported wrist numbness, and that an oral explanation had been given to both the patient and the person with her before anesthesia. The defense also suggested that the client's recurrent shoulder dislocations may have left the plexus partially damaged before the operation. An appraisal obtained at the defendants' request assessed a 30 percent pre-existing contribution.
Taeshin's Approach
Taeshin Law Firm did not rely on the operative record alone. The team worked through the earlier treatment records to answer the pre-existing injury theory, obtained a medical record appraisal, used the court's document production procedure to surface outpatient notes, and then defended the first-instance findings on appeal.
On the pre-existing condition question, the firm analyzed responses from the clinics that had treated the client before surgery. Those records documented shoulder pain, but contained no note of the arm numbness, paralysis or swelling that accompanies a nerve injury. The firm also observed that nerve symptoms caused by dislocation typically improve within months, whereas this client's deficit was permanent, and that no nerve study had been performed before the operation.
In the appraisal obtained at the plaintiff's request, the appraiser responded that there were no preoperative findings of nerve injury, that the damage was related to the surgical and anesthetic technique, and that there was no indication that another cause had intervened.
On traction, the firm argued that there was no evidence the 10-kilogram entry was a clerical error and that Korean clinical practice does not record traction in pounds. It also argued that performing the block without ultrasound increased the risk to the plexus.
To establish what the hospital knew after the operation, the firm used a court order requiring production of documents. The outpatient progress notes disclosed references to a numb thumb, a weak arm and wrist drop. The firm used those entries to show that the significance of the complaints should have been apparent, yet no further testing was arranged for about three months.
On appeal, the firm met the pre-existing contribution argument directly. Even the appraisal commissioned by the defense described a pre-existing injury only as a possibility and identified no objective test supporting it. The firm also relied on Supreme Court precedent distinguishing a pre-existing contribution from disability that existed before the incident, and argued that the defense had established neither.
Outcome
The first-instance court declined to accept the argument that the traction entry was a mistake. It noted that the record stated the figure in kilograms and found no basis for treating it as an error. It also addressed the suggestion of a pre-existing nerve injury, observing that the opinion rested on entries in the medical record without objective test data, and held that this alone could not establish another cause.
The court found that the medical staff had failed to exercise the care required to avoid injuring the brachial plexus, and that continuing observation without additional testing during the outpatient period was not appropriate. It further found a breach of the duty to explain: the surgical consent form did not describe the block, and the explanation was given to the person accompanying the client rather than to the client herself.
The defendants appealed. In the appellate proceedings the court issued a settlement recommendation decision. Under Korean civil procedure, a court may propose terms for resolving a case, and if neither side objects within the statutory period, the recommendation becomes final and binds the parties in the manner of a settlement. The recommended terms required the defendants to pay the client 280 million won jointly, with the client waiving the remainder of her claim. The recommendation became final, and the dispute was concluded on those terms.
Because the matter ended through a settlement recommendation rather than a full appellate judgment, the outcome should be understood as the terms the court considered appropriate to resolve the dispute, not as a finding on every issue the parties contested.
What This Case Shows
The case illustrates how two features of shoulder surgery can combine to endanger the same nerves. Traction applied during the operation and anesthetic delivered beside the brachial plexus each place the nerve bundle under stress, and a medical malpractice claim may need to examine both. The operative record of traction and the technique used for the block therefore deserve close attention.
It also shows why postoperative nerve symptoms call for objective investigation. Numbness, weakness and wrist drop are not ordinary recovery complaints, and the interval between the first report of such symptoms and the first nerve study can determine whether an injury is treatable or permanent. In this case that interval was about three months, and the deficit remained, which supported an argument of hospital negligence in the follow-up care.
The case further shows that in Korea the duty to explain a procedure is directed to the patient. A consent form that omits a procedure, or an explanation given only to a companion, may not satisfy that duty. For foreign patients and international families, this is a reminder to ask what each planned procedure involves and to have risks explained directly, with interpretation where needed, and to check how to obtain medical records in Korea early.
For the defense side, the case is a reminder that a pre-existing condition argument gains force from objective testing, not from the possibility that an earlier condition explains the damage. Records that document shoulder pain but not neurological findings may not support the inference.
Related Practice Areas
Facing a Similar Situation?
Claims involving nerve injury after surgery or regional anesthesia depend heavily on the operative record, the follow-up notes and the timing of objective testing. For a confidential consultation about a medical malpractice matter in Korea, contact Taeshin Law Firm.
Related Success Cases
Anesthesia Malpractice Resulting in Quadriplegia and Brain Damage: 2.2 Billion Won in Korea
Medical MalpracticeUreteral Injury During Laparoscopic Hysterectomy in Korea: A 250 Million Won Court-Mediated Resolution
Medical MalpracticeMisdiagnosed Plantar Neuroma After Two Foot Surgeries: 110 Million Won Settlement