Hit-and-Run Allegation in Korea Ends Without Charges After a Minor Tire Contact
2026 Nov
Case Overview
A driver was accused of leaving the scene of a traffic accident after another motorist reported that their vehicle had been struck and that the driver and a passenger had been injured. The client had felt no impact at the time and had driven home. About a month later, the police contacted him, and the case was referred to prosecutors on charges of hit-and-run causing injury and failure to take measures after an accident. Taeshin Law Firm represented the client during the prosecutorial stage. After a supplementary investigation that included a polygraph examination, prosecutors closed the case with a disposition of "no charges" based on insufficient evidence. No indictment followed and no trial took place.
Background
The client was in regular employment with no criminal record. He was driving through an intersection in the early evening when another vehicle appeared suddenly from the side. He turned the steering wheel sharply to avoid a collision and continued to his destination. He had not felt the vehicles touch.
About a month later, the police contacted him about an alleged hit-and-run. The complainant alleged that the client had changed lanes without properly checking the surrounding traffic, struck the rear of the complainant's vehicle, and left without providing assistance even though the driver and a passenger had been injured. The complainant stated that they had attended a clinic for several months and sought reimbursement of treatment costs.
The police concluded that both allegations were established and referred the matter to the prosecution. The offences identified were fleeing after causing injury under Article 5-3(2) of the Act on Aggravated Punishment, etc. of Specific Crimes and failure to take necessary measures after a traffic accident under Article 54 of the Road Traffic Act.
Key Legal Issues
Fleeing after causing injury carries a minimum of one year's imprisonment or a fine of between five million and thirty million won. Unlike an ordinary traffic accident, it is not an offence that can be resolved through insurance alone or by reaching a civil settlement with the injured party.
The offence requires that the driver knew an accident had occurred and that a person had been injured, and nevertheless left the scene. In this case, neither the contact nor the departure was disputed. The decisive question was whether the client was aware of the accident.
Korean courts assess that awareness from objective circumstances rather than from the driver's assertion. The relevant factors include the force and location of the impact, the damage to each vehicle, how the driver behaved immediately afterward, whether there was any reason to flee, and whether other vehicles or witnesses were present. A finding that an accident occurred does not, by itself, establish that the driver knew of it. The same principle applies at the prosecutorial stage, where a referral by the police is reviewed independently rather than accepted as final.
Defense Strategy
The defense began by setting out the framework that courts apply when judging whether a driver knew of an accident, and submitted around ten lower court decisions in which drivers had been acquitted on comparable facts.
The physical evidence pointed to a very minor contact. The complainant's vehicle had only a diagonal mark above the rear wheel. Its height was consistent with the rubber of the client's tires rather than with bodywork. The client's own vehicle had no damage at all, a fact confirmed on the day of the incident by both a police officer and an insurance adjuster. The defense also explained that vehicles of different weights respond differently to the same contact, so a light touch can be imperceptible in one car while producing a noticeable jolt in another.
Footage from the client's dashcam showed that he did not accelerate after the contact. He drove slowly enough to be overtaken repeatedly, did not stop, and did not leave the vehicle until he reached home. When the police later contacted him, he examined the car, found no marks, and went to the police station.
The defense also addressed motive. The vehicle was covered by comprehensive automobile insurance and the client held driver's insurance. There was no allegation of drinking or unlicensed driving. The contact occurred in daylight on a busy road, which made fleeing both unnecessary and impractical. If the client had known of the accident, submitting an insurance claim would have been the simpler course.
Because the case turned on the client's state of mind, the defense requested a polygraph examination from the outset of the police investigation. The examination was administered during the prosecutor's supplementary investigation. The client's statements that he had not known of the accident produced truthful responses.
Outcome
Prosecutors issued a disposition of "no charges" on the ground that the evidence was insufficient. The reasoning rested on three points: the client's vehicle was undamaged and the complainant's vehicle bore only a mark consistent with tire contact, making a significant movement inside the other car unlikely and indicating a minor accident; there was no discernible motive to flee; and the polygraph results supported the client's account that he had been unaware of the accident. The mere fact that he left the scene did not prove that he knew of the collision and intended to depart.
No indictment was issued, no trial was held, and no criminal record resulted. The client also avoided being treated as a hit-and-run driver, which had been a central concern alongside the possible criminal penalty.
What This Case Shows
This case illustrates that leaving the scene of an accident is not, on its own, enough to establish the offence of fleeing after causing injury. Prosecutors must show that the driver knew of the accident and of the injury.
For drivers in Korea, the practical lessons are about evidence. Photographs of both vehicles should be taken immediately, before repairs, and dashcam footage should be preserved before it is overwritten. Records of insurance coverage, and evidence that there was no drinking or unlicensed driving, help explain why flight made no sense. Where awareness is disputed, a polygraph examination may be available during the investigation.
The case also shows that a police referral is not the end of the matter. The prosecutor reviews the evidence independently, and submissions at that stage can change the outcome.
Foreign drivers face the same legal standards, with additional practical burdens. Language and interpretation must be arranged early, and it should not be assumed that leaving the scene can be resolved through insurance or a private settlement. The Road Traffic Act requires a driver to stop and take measures after an accident regardless of who was at fault.
The result in this case depended on its specific facts and evidence. It is not a guarantee that a similar allegation will end the same way. Matters of this kind are handled as part of Taeshin Law Firm's criminal defense practice.
Lead Counsel
Related Practice Areas
Facing a Similar Situation?
Hit-and-run allegations depend heavily on what the driver knew at the time of the contact, and on the objective evidence about the force of the impact. For a confidential consultation regarding a criminal matter in Korea, contact Taeshin Law Firm.
Related Success Cases
Acquittal in a Korean Lane-Change Graze Case Where a Two-Week Injury Was Not Proven
Criminal DefenseSerious Injury in an Unprotected Left Turn Ends Without Prosecution After a Pre-Indictment Settlement
Criminal DefenseParking Lot Entrance Fatal Traffic Accident on Appeal: Suspended Sentence Secured